Visas for the dead: ashes of Pakistani Hindus can’t get to the Ganges

1 / 6
The image taken in September 2019 shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)
2 / 6
The image taken in September 2019 shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)
3 / 6
The image taken in September 2019 shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)
4 / 6
A view of Karachi's Hindu crematorium, which is the only cremation ground for the 250,000 Hindus who live in Pakistan's largest city, on Sept. 11, 2019. (AN photo)
5 / 6
The image taken in September 2019 shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)
6 / 6
The image taken in September 2019 shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)
Updated 14 September 2019
Follow

Visas for the dead: ashes of Pakistani Hindus can’t get to the Ganges

  • Getting visas to take cremated remains to India was always difficult, even before tensions escalated
  • Roughly 4 million Hindus live in Pakistan, with a majority of them in Sindh

KARACHI: The teeming metropolis of Karachi, a melting pot of religions, ethnicities and languages, has a single cremation ground and the ashes of over a hundred Pakistani Hindus waiting to reach the River Ganges, buried for now, under the bureaucracy of a strict Indian visa regime.
With a Hindu population estimated at roughly 4 million in the Muslim majority country of 208 million people, most members of the community live in Pakistan’s southeastern province of Sindh.
Over 250,000 Hindus live in Karachi city alone, with its crematorium next to a dilapidated Hindu graveyard. In Hindu practice, cremation grounds are usually built near rivers or freshwater streams, so the ashes of the deceased can be disposed of easily and quickly.
But for many of Pakistan’s Hindus, whose ancestors remained in Muslim Pakistan during the partition of the sub-continent in 1947, a last wish to cross the border into India is gathering dust.
Among almost a hundred others, in a small room are the asthi, or cremated remains, of Atam Parkash, a Pakistani-Hindu businessman who died of cancer in May this year, and who asked that his ashes be taken to the ancient city of Haridwar in northern India, where the River Ganges, considered holy by most Hindus, exits the Himalayan foothills. The river is the site of thousands of cremations and ash scatterings every day.
“My brother asked that his asthi be scattered in the River Ganges, but I don’t know if we will ever be able to fulfil his wish,” his brother, Sunny Ghansham, told Arab News. His fears are not unfounded.




A view of Karachi's Hindu crematorium, which is the only cremation ground for the 250,000 Hindus who live in Pakistan's largest city, on Sept. 11, 2019. (AN photo)

Relations between Pakistan and India, both nuclear-armed countries, have always been strained primarily over the disputed Kashmir valley, which both own in part but claim in full.
On August 5th, tensions dramatically escalated when India flooded the valley with troops, restricted movements and cut off communications as Prime Minister Narendra Modi withdrew special rights for Indian-administered Kashmir. Pakistan responded by downgrading diplomatic ties, stopping all transport links and banning bilateral trade alongside making appeals to the UN and international community.
As a result, already hard-to-get Indian visas have now become a near impossibility, and it appears the ashes of some of Pakistan’s Hindus might never reach their desired resting places.
“Although currently strained ties have increased our worries, obtaining visas for taking asthis (across the border) was never an easy job,” said Shri Ram Nath, caretaker of the Karachi Shamshan Gath, or crematorium, who took charge of the institution in 2005, and found the remains of hundreds of people dumped inside a small room.
“When I entered the room, I saw hundreds of remains lying one over the other... like trash,” Ram Nath said.
“I inquired of the staff who told me those (remains) were lying there for Asthi Visarjan (immersion) in Ganga Mayian (River Ganges). When I checked closely, I found the remains of a man, his son and grandson among them,” he said.
After investigating the case, Ram Nath discovered that years ago, a man waiting for an Indian visa had kept the ashes of his father at the crematorium, but died before it was issued. His son then brought his ashes to the cremation ground, and hoped to one day scatter them in the River Ganges. His visa never came either, and he too, died in waiting.
Ram Nath called a community meeting and 50 Pakistani Hindus, whose friends and families had asked for their ashes to be scattered in Haridwar, applied for Indian visas. All were refused.
“Finally, in January 2011, with the help of some NGO’s in India, we got 11 Visas and took 135 remains (to the River Ganges), including those of the three generations of one family,” Ram Nath said.
In September 2016, Ram Nath was able to take 160 more remains to India but since then, a gap of three years has meant the arrival of over a hundred remains in-waiting for the Ganges, that now crowd the small room of the city’s only cremation site.
“If Pakistan can open Kartarpur despite tense relations, why can’t the relatives of deceased Pakistani Hindus be allowed...to go to India to take their ashes to Haridwar,” Sunny Ghansham said, referring to the proposed border corridor between India and Pakistan to facilitate Indian Sikh pilgrims coming to Pakistan.




The image taken on September 11, 2019, shows the cremated remains of Pakistani Hindus, marked and stored sometimes for years, in a small room at Karachi's only cremation ground. (AN photo)

But relations between New Delhi and Islamabad are only getting more tense, with diplomatic courtesies largely suspended.
In August, the last ‘friendship’ bus from Delhi to Lahore, a popular means of travel between the two countries, pulled into a deserted bus stop and terminated service. Earlier this month, Pakistan refused to allow India’s President the use of its airspace, and Islamabad has been campaigning profusely for New Delhi’s international condemnation. India has defended itself by saying the constitutional revocation is Delhi’s ‘internal matter,’ and accuses Pakistan of smuggling militants across the border to fuel an insurgency in its part of Kashmir, a charge Pakistan vehemently denies.
Not all Hindus in Pakistan choose the Ganges in India for the scattering of their ashes, however. In fact, Ram Nath said, most ashes are immersed in the River Indus, which is also considered holy.
“Not all wish (for it), but those who do ask that their ashes be taken to Haridwar... we are obligated to fulfil their wish,” he said.
The immersion of ashes is also done at a point near the Karachi port, he said, but with increased littering and the mixing of sewage water, it is no longer considered a desirable place for the dead.
“We are bound to honor the will of the deceased,” Ram Nath said. “But it seems hard... very hard now.”


Pakistan’s northwestern province offers over Rs10 billion to keep national airline under state control

Updated 18 min 24 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan’s northwestern province offers over Rs10 billion to keep national airline under state control

  • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa says PIA is a critical state asset that should remain ‘within the national fold’
  • Offer comes after PIA’s privatization process led to a low bid that fell far short of the minimum price

KARACHI: Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) province has formally offered to exceed the highest bid in the sale of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA), saying the national flag carrier should remain under government control to preserve its status, according to a letter from provincial authorities to federal officials that emerged on Saturday.
KP made the offer just a day after the government held the privatization process, receiving the sole bid of Rs10 billion ($36 million) from Blue World City, a real estate development firm, which fell far short of the minimum price of Rs85 billion ($305 million).
Critics, including PIA union representatives and independent analysts, called the low bid an “embarrassment” for the government, with airline employees suggesting Pakistani authorities should expand PIA’s fleet to restore its operational viability.
“On behalf of the Chief Minister ... and the people of KP, we would like to express our earnest interest in participating in the bidding process for the sale of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA),” read the letter from the provincial Board of Investment and Trade. “This letter serves as our formal intent to position the Government of KP as a competitive bidder in this strategic acquisition.”
The letter, which was addressed to Pakistan’s Privatization Minister Abdul Aleem Khan on Friday, emphasized PIA’s importance as “a critical asset that symbolizes our national identity and pride,” adding that the province wished to keep it “within the national fold.”
“The Chief Minister [Ali Amin Gandapur] has directed us to actively pursue this acquisition to ensure the airline remains under the control of the Government of Pakistan rather than transferring to any private or foreign-backed entity,” it continued.
“In line with this commitment, we are prepared to offer a bid that will surpass the current highest offer of PKR 10 Billion by Blue World Consortium, ensuring a strong and competitive position within this process,” it added.
Pakistan decided to move ahead with PIA’s privatization under terms agreed with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for a 37-month, $7 billion bailout approved in September, aiming to divest over 51 percent of its stake in the financially struggling national carrier.
The KP administration requested a prompt meeting with federal officials to present its detailed proposal and outline its vision for PIA, affirming its readiness to proceed quickly to secure the acquisition.
Despite KP’s proposed plan, provincial ownership of PIA may not align with the privatization’s intended purpose under the IMF agreement, which is to reduce financial burdens associated with state-owned enterprises.


‘He never found peace’: Former Guantanamo detainee from Pakistan dies after years of suffering

Updated 5 sec ago
Follow

‘He never found peace’: Former Guantanamo detainee from Pakistan dies after years of suffering

  • Abdul Rahim Ghulam Rabban died after prolonged illness due to a lack of proper medical care
  • Arrested in Karachi in 2002, he spent about two decades at the US prison without ever being charged

KARACHI: A former Guantanamo Bay prisoner from Karachi, who spent about two decades at the detention center without being charged before his return home in February last year, died in his native city on Friday, his brother and a fellow former detainee confirmed on Saturday.
Abdul Rahim Ghulam Rabbani’s death was attributed by his brother, Muhammad Ahmed Ghulam Rabbani, to inadequate medical care during a prolonged illness, which he said extended their suffering even after their transfer to Pakistan.
According to Reprieve, a global legal action non-profit, the brothers endured 545 days of torture in CIA custody following their arrest in Karachi on September 10, 2002, before being transferred to Guantanamo in 2004.
“We spent over twenty arduous years together in Guantanamo,” said the late former Guantanamo detainee’s brother. “On Friday at 2 AM, he passed away in my arms.”
Guantanamo Bay, a US military detention facility established in Cuba to detain suspects in the “War on Terror” after the September 11, 2001, attacks, became notorious for holding prisoners without trials, drawing widespread condemnation.
International human rights groups criticized the facility for violating detainees’ rights to due process, with allegations of extreme interrogation techniques amounting to torture, including waterboarding and prolonged isolation.
Rabbani recalled that both brothers briefly felt relief when they learned they would be handed over to Pakistani authorities, believing their ordeal would end.
“But our suffering continued,” he said. “Over 19 months, we still lack identity cards. My brother had been ill for a long time, but we couldn’t access proper medical care without an ID.”
He added that his brother fell “seriously ill” more than 20 times, attributing it to injections administered upon their arrival at Guantanamo and the extensive torture they endured.
“He suffered such violence that his hand was broken, his leg was broken and his private parts were damaged, ruining his family life,” Rabbani said. “When he passed away, we even faced difficulties in burying him because an ID card was required.”
Overwhelmed by their circumstances, he questioned why they were returned to Pakistan when their own government was unwilling to issue identity documents.
“My dearest brother has left me behind,” he added. “He did not have peace for even a single day after the arrest. What was our crime? What is our crime?”
In the early 2000s, Pakistan apprehended and transferred hundreds of individuals to US custody, claiming they were linked to Al Qaeda. In his 2006 memoir, In the Line of Fire, then-President Pervez Musharraf said his government had received substantial CIA payments for these handovers.
Subsequent analyzes revealed that many of these detainees, mistakenly identified as militants, were likely innocent.
Lahore-based analyst Majid Nizami called the Rabbani brothers’ arrest “a case of illegal abduction by state agencies of Pakistan,” later justified as “mistaken identity.”
“It’s unclear whether this was intentional by Pakistani agencies or a severe negligence,” he told Arab News. “It has not yet been determined who was responsible, and no one seems interested in addressing the issue.”
According to some estimates, Pakistani authorities handed over nearly 370 people to the US after 9/11. The two brothers were among those transferred to American custody for $5,000 each.


Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to establish power transmission line costing $28 million

Updated 02 November 2024
Follow

Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to establish power transmission line costing $28 million

  • Official says this will be the first time ever that a province will lay a transmission line on its own
  • In the first phase, a 40-kilometer section of the line will be built from Matiltan to Madyan in Swat

ISLAMABAD: The government in Pakistan’s northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province has signed an agreement with a private firm to establish a power transmission line in the province, an official said on Saturday.
The power transmission line will be established in one and a half year with a cost of Rs8 billion ($28.8 million), according to Muhammad Ali Saif, KP chief minister’s adviser on information.
In the first phase, a 40-kilometer section of the line will be built from Matiltan to Madyan in Swat to supply power to local industries and national grid.
“Industries will be provided very cheap electricity through the transmission line,” Saif said in a statement. “The completion of its first phase generate Rs7 billion for the province.”
Pakistan has enough installed capacity to meet its demand for electricity, but the South Asian country lacks adequate resources and cannot afford to invest in new infrastructure and power lines, which often result in transmission losses. 
In January 2023, the country suffered a nationwide blackout due to a frequency failure in the national grid, which happened because of a major mismatch between demand and supply. It was the second nationwide shutdown in three months. 
In November last year, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) approved $250 million loan for Pakistan to help the South Asian country deliver reliable electricity by expanding and improving its power transmission network in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab provinces.
 


Hindus, Muslims gather in unity to celebrate Diwali at historic Karachi temple

Updated 02 November 2024
Follow

Hindus, Muslims gather in unity to celebrate Diwali at historic Karachi temple

  • Diwali honors the victorious return of Lord Rama, one of Hinduism’s most revered figures, from exile
  • Devotees light up homes and workplaces, distribute sweetmeats and wear colorful clothes to mark festival

KARACHI: Thousands of men, women and children, both Hindus and Muslims, gathered on Friday at the 234-year-old Shri Swaminarayan temple in the southern Pakistani port city of Karachi to celebrate one of the biggest Hindu festivals, Diwali.

Diwali honors the victorious return of Lord Rama, one of Hinduism’s most revered figures, from exile and was celebrated in various parts of the world either on Thursday or Friday.

It is also known as the festival of lights to symbolize the triumph of light over darkness, or good over evil, explaining why fireworks are so central to the Diwali celebrations.

The Swaminarayan temple, situated in the Serai Quarters area, is not only frequented by Hindus living in the neighborhood, but members of the community from elsewhere in the bustling megapolis too.

“Diwali is a festival of happiness, a festival of lights. Our lord Rama returned to Ayodhya after 14 years in exile. His wife Sita and his [younger] brother Laxman were also with him, who stood by him,” Hansa Rani, an academic, told Arab News, lighting up small oil lamps, called ‘diyas,’ to welcome their Lord.

“We celebrate their return with happiness [on Diwali], wear new clothes, distribute sweets and make rangoli [in which] we decorate our floor with colors.”

A Hindu woman and a young girl hold clay-lamps during a ceremony to celebrate Diwali, the festival of lights, at Somi Narin temple, in Karachi on November 1, 2024. (AP)


One of the most prominent Hindu festivals, Diwali is celebrated across the globe wherever the community resides. Devotees light up their homes and workplaces to signify light over darkness.

The festivities span over the course of five days, starting with ‘Dhanteras,’ that marks the first day of Diwali, followed by ‘Naraka Chaturdashi’ [Choti Diwali], Diwali, ‘Govardhan Puja’ and Bhai Dooj. Each day has different rituals and significance.

Pakistani Hindu women celebrate 'Diwali', the festival of lights, at the Krishna Temple in Lahore on November 1, 2024. (AFP)

“We are here to celebrate Diwali. As you can see, how happy these people are. There is one festival in the entire year during which we have mithai (sweetmeats), worship, light diyas, and meet our relatives,” Gauri Dara, who was at the temple with her family, told Arab News, on the sidelines of the celebrations.

“On this day, our cousins from other cities come to meet us too. We celebrate Diwali together.”

Children light firecrackers during 'Diwali' festival celebrations in Karachi on November 1, 2024. (AFP)

Muslims, who attended the celebrations at the Swaminarayan temple, said they had come to stand in solidarity with their Hindu brothers and sisters and share their happiness on the joyous occasion.

“[Despite] being a Muslim, I come here every year since the past 10 years in fact. I love the fact that we get to celebrate Diwali with our Hindu community every year because I have a lot of Hindu friends in Pakistan,” Qasim Shafique, a senior television news producer, told Arab News.

“Our flag also represents [minorities]. The white part in the [Pakistani] flag is for minorities. So, I come to celebrate that every year. I’ll meet all my Hindu friends here and we will enjoy the festivities together.”


Pakistan PM calls for justice for journalists killed in Gaza

Updated 02 November 2024
Follow

Pakistan PM calls for justice for journalists killed in Gaza

  • Shehbaz Sharif’s statement came on the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes against Journalists
  • The Pakistan prime minister says freedom of press is not possible without the protection of journalists

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Saturday demanded the world hold Israel accountable for the killing of dozens of journalists in Gaza, Sharif’s office said.
Sharif’s statement came on the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes against Journalists, a United Nations-recognized international day that is observed annually on Nov. 2.
Since Israel began its war against Hamas on Oct. 7, 2023, at least 134 journalists have been killed and 41 injured in Gaza, the West Bank, Israel and Lebanon, according to the Committee to Protect Journalists.
In his statement, Sharif lamented that dozens of journalists were “deliberately” killed in Gaza to block the “path of truth,” despite the international conventions to protect journalists.
“The United Nations and international organizations should bring Israel to justice for the massacre of journalists,” he said. “Freedom of press is not possible without the protection of journalists.”
Sharif said his government was determined to prevent crimes against journalists, ensure punishment of perpetrators and protect journalists.
“The Constitution of Pakistan gives the right to freedom of expression, freedom of press and access to information, and the Government of Pakistan ensures this,” he added.
Pakistan itself consistently ranks among the most dangerous countries for journalists, with many facing threats, intimidation, and violence. According to the CPJ, 103 journalists and media workers have been killed in Pakistan between 1992 and 2024.