Activists cry foul as Pakistan government moves to strengthen laws to curb social media 'blackmailing, harassment'

In this file photo, an IT professional browses Facebook in Lahore, Pakistan, on May 27, 2010. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 15 July 2022
Follow

Activists cry foul as Pakistan government moves to strengthen laws to curb social media 'blackmailing, harassment'

  • Interior minister directs authorities take immediate action against such crimes
  • Digital rights activists accuse authorities of trying to stifle free speech, press

ISLAMABAD: The Pakistani government has decided to crack down on social media users involved in "harassment" and "blackmailing" of citizens as well as promotion of "immoral content and obscene videos," the country's interior minister said on Friday, vowing to strengthen the cybercrime laws to curb these practices.  

The development comes as Pakistani authorities attempt to neutralize social media narratives critical of the government and the country's powerful military establishment through amendments in existing laws, but all their efforts have proven to be futile so far. 

In 2016, the then Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) government enacted the Pakistan Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) to check crime on social media and other internet platforms. The successive Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government also tried to make the law more stringent through amendments, but it had to back off in the wake of backlash from journalists and digital rights activists. 

While the government says such online practices are “unacceptable,” digital rights activists see it as an attempt to stifle dissent. 

“The defamation of citizens through character assassination and insulting material on the social media is totally unacceptable,” Pakistan's Interior Minister Rana Sanaullah said in a statement, after presiding over a high-level meeting on "harassment" and "blackmailing" of the citizens and uploading of "obscene videos" on social media.  

The interior minister has directed the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) director-general for “immediate action” against those involved in such crimes.  

“The presence of immoral and insulting content on social media and its promotion could spread anarchy in the society,” Sanaullah said. He urged people to lodge their complaints regarding social media harassment and character assassination with the FIA. 

The Ministry of Interior has also decided to constitute a working group to introduce necessary amendments in PECA to make the law more stringent and effective. “The working group will look into the legislation and administrative actions required to stop harassment, character assassination and uploading of insulting material on social media,” it said.  

A spokesperson for the interior ministry told Arab News the working group would be made public as soon as it was notified and that it would submit its recommendations to the ministry after consultation with all stakeholders.  

Digital rights activists, however, say successive governments in Pakistan have used PECA to persecute political opponents and stifle free speech and press through this “draconian and notorious” law.  

Usama Khilji, director of 'Bolo Bhi' digital rights advocacy group, said there was no need to bring more changes to the law as “it would end up undermining the freedom of speech and freedom of press that is enshrined in our constitution.”  

“Cyber stalking and online harassment are already punishable offences in PECA,” he said. “Uploading and promotion of child pornography and morphing of photos and videos on social media platforms are also included in PECA.”  

Khilji said political parties make “short-sighted plans” to curb dissent after coming into power, however, the civil society must resist any such move.  

Nighat Dad, executive-director of Digital Rights Foundation, said all political parties in Pakistan, whether they were in power or opposition, tried to suppress the dissenting voices through PECA.  

“The Islamabad High Court has already struck down section 20 of PECA relating to criminal defamation by terming it unconstitutional,” she told Arab News. “But it seems like the government wants to bring it back now through another amendment.”  

Dad said the government should focus on strengthening the criminal justice system and implementation of existing laws to provide justice to public instead of trying to make PECA more stringent. “The right to freedom of speech and freedom of expression must be protected as long as it doesn’t hurt anybody physically offline,” she said. “People have every right to criticize public representatives and hold them accountable, so this right must be protected both in online spaces and offline.” 


‘Between Sacred Cities’: Pakistan’s Imran Qureshi unveils largest installation at Islamic Arts Biennale

Updated 14 sec ago
Follow

‘Between Sacred Cities’: Pakistan’s Imran Qureshi unveils largest installation at Islamic Arts Biennale

  • Installation reimagines historic route that stretched from Kufa in Iraq to holy city of Makkah
  • Qureshi, a Pakistani visual artist, has featured artworks in local and international exhibitions

ISLAMABAD: Pakistani artist Imran Qureshi on Saturday unveiled “Between Sacred Cities,” the largest installation at the Islamic Arts Biennale 2025 in Jeddah, his art reimagining a historic route that once stretched from Kufa in Iraq to the holy city of Makkah. 

The Islamic Arts Biennale 2025 provides a platform for new discourse about Islamic arts, featuring contemporary and newly commissioned artworks with historical objects from Islamic cultures. It offers artists a platform to explore themes of spirituality, identity, and the intersection of past and present. This year’s biennale will run from Jan. 25-May 25. 

According to Lotus, a public relations agency, the installation is situated between the iconic Makkah and Madina pavilions at the Western Hajj Terminal. 

“The installation reimagines a historic route that once stretched from Kufa, Iraq, to Makkah,” Lotus said. 

“Designed to aid pilgrims on their Hajj journey, this route served as a network of resting stations and water sources, inspiring Qureshi’s interpretation of an oasis as a sanctuary of rest, reflection, and unity.”

The statement said that the concept of an oasis in the installation is transformed into an interactive and contemplative garden-like structure, central to which is an octagonal design. 

“Drawing on the spiritual essence of the journey between Makkah and Madina, the installation incorporates the holy water of Zamzam and lush greenery reminiscent of Madina’s tranquillity,” it added. 

Qureshi has used vibrant woven strips to symbolize flowing water while the surrounding greenery evokes a sense of life, Lotus said. 

The installation has been commissioned by the Diriyah Biennale Foundation and curated by acclaimed artist Muhannad Shono. 

“Between Sacred Cities will be on display from January 25, 2025, to May 25, 2025, offering visitors an unparalleled opportunity to explore the universal themes of travel, spirituality, and interconnectedness,” Lotus said. 

Qureshi is a visual artist from Pakistan’s southern Sindh province. With a career spanning twenty-nine years, encompassing local and international exhibitions, he has emerged as a prominent Pakistani artist.

In 2013, he created a large-scale, site-specific work for The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Roof Garden Commission in New York. The same year he was awarded the Deutsche Bank’s Artist of the Year and exhibited solo for the first time in Europe at the Deutsche Bank Kunsthalle in Berlin. 

Qureshi’s work has since been shown in numerous solo exhibitions, including the Barbican Center, London (2016), Kunsten Museum of Modern Art, Aalborg, Denmark (2016), along with executing site-specific projects at the Washington National Cathedral, Washington, D.C. (2018) and Al Ain, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates (2018), to name a few. 

In 2021 he was awarded the Sitara-e-Imtiaz (Star of Excellence) by Pakistan’s government.


Imran Khan’s party moves top court against Pakistan constitutional amendment on judicial reforms

Updated 47 min 15 sec ago
Follow

Imran Khan’s party moves top court against Pakistan constitutional amendment on judicial reforms

  • Urges top court to declare amendment null and void as votes to pass it were obtained via “harassment”
  • Pakistan’s ruling coalition government says only parliament has power to roll back constitutional amendments

ISLAMABAD: Former prime minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party announced on Saturday it has challenged a contentious constitutional amendment on judicial reforms in the Supreme Court, urging the top court to declare it null and void as the government allegedly harassed opposition lawmakers to have it passed in parliament.

The ruling coalition government passed the contentious 26th constitutional amendment bill from both houses of parliament in October 2024, amid stiff resistance from opposition parties and the legal fraternity. Both argued the government’s move was an attempt to curtail the independence of the judiciary, a charge it denies. 

The amendments empower a parliamentary committee to appoint the Supreme Court’s chief justice for a fixed term of three years. It also called for the creation of new group of senior judges to weigh exclusively on constitutional issues. 

The government secured 225 votes of the required 224 in the National Assembly, or the lower house of parliament, with the help of a handful of rebel lawmakers from the PTI. The party has claimed that the government harassed and intimidated opposition lawmakers and their families to secure the votes. The government denies the allegations vehemently. 

“Legal team representing Pakistan Tehreek e Insaf has challenged the 26th amendment in the Supreme Court of Pakistan, requesting to declare its status null & void along with constitutional benches formation & decisions by the judicial bench,” a statement from the party said. 

The PTI alleged that lawmakers were harassed and abducted to ensure the amendments were passed. 

“The 26th amendment was opposed by the party at many levels that publicly criticized the process of pushing through the 26th amendment, with individuals being coerced into voting and genuine consent was not involved,” the PTI added. 

As per a summary of the petition filed in the Supreme Court, the party has maintained that the 26th amendment introduces “unprecedented and substantial” changes to the fundamental structure and salient features of the constitution. 

The development takes place a day after Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, the chairman of the government’s key coalition partner Pakistan Peoples Party, said only parliament has the power to roll back the 26th constitutional amendment. 

“As far as rolling back the 26th [constitutional] amendment is concerned, that power only rests with this institution,” Bhutto Zardari told reporters at the National Assembly, referring to the lower house of parliament. 

“Neither will we accept nor will the nation nor anyone else if the constitution is rolled back or undermined by another institution.”

TENSIONS WITH THE TOP COURT

The amendment fixing the top justice’s retirement age was passed days before Qazi Faez Isa, the then chief justice, was due to retire. 

Khan’s PTI frequently accused Isa of being aligned with the government, its chief rival, an allegation the government has always rejected. Khan’s party repeatedly said the amendments were aimed at granting an extension in tenure to Isa.

Under the previous law, Isa would have been automatically replaced by the most senior judge behind him, currently Justice Mansoor Ali Shah, who consistently issued verdicts deemed favorable to Khan and the PTI.

Sharif’s government has said the bill ensures parliament will not remain “a rubber stamp” one in the wake of its tensions with the judiciary, which were on the rise since the February national election of last year.


Pakistan’s national airline suspends 5 crew members for allegedly smuggling cell phones

Updated 25 January 2025
Follow

Pakistan’s national airline suspends 5 crew members for allegedly smuggling cell phones

  • Customs seized “expensive” mobile phones from crew members after arrival of Dubai-Multan flight on Jan. 22, says PIA
  • The national airline earlier this week dismissed two crew members for smuggling mobile phones in October last year

KARACHI: Pakistan’s national airline this week suspended five crew members for allegedly smuggling cell phones into the country, a spokesperson of the flag carrier confirmed on Saturday, vowing to enforce a “zero tolerance” policy for those found guilty of wrongdoings. 

Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) on Jan. 23 issued a show cause notice to five crew members, two of them air hostesses and two stewards, saying that customs authorities had seized “expensive” mobile phones from them on Jan. 22 after the arrival of the PIA flight PK-222 to Multan from Dubai. . 

“PIA has already started the process of probing the incident and if found guilty, the crew will be subjected to the strict most administrative action,” PIA spokesperson Abdullah Khan told Arab News. 

“The spokesperson reiterates PIA’s position of zero tolerance in case any of its staff members are found involved in nefarious activities,” he added. 

The airline did not disclose how many smuggled mobile phones were allegedly recovered from the five crew members. 

The development took place a day after the airline fired two crew members, an air hostess and a steward, after finding them guilty of smuggling mobile phones in October from Toronto. Customs authorities seized the mobile phones from the two crew members after the arrival of flight PK-798 from Toronto to Lahore on Oct. 5, 2024, as per a copy of the dismissal notice seen by Arab News

The loss-making PIA has proven to be a headache for successive Pakistani governments over the years, needing frequent financial bailouts to function. 

PIA posted losses of $270 million in 2023, according to local media. Its liabilities were nearly $3 billion, about five times the total worth of its assets.

PIA, which employs 7,000 people, has long been accused of being bloated and poorly run — hobbled by unpaid bills, a poor safety record and regulatory issues.

Pakistan’s government has said it is committed to privatizing the debt-ridden airline and has been scrambling to find a buyer. Late last year, a deal fell through after a potential buyer reportedly offered a fraction of the asking price.


Pakistan minister criticizes opposition for ‘unilaterally’ ending talks with government

Updated 25 January 2025
Follow

Pakistan minister criticizes opposition for ‘unilaterally’ ending talks with government

  • Information Minister Ataullah Tarar says Imran Khan’s party ended talks “in a hurry with ill intention”
  • Khan’s PTI has ruled out further talks unless government forms judicial commissions to probe protests

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Information Minister Ataullah Tarar this week criticized former prime minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party for ending negotiations “unilaterally” with the government, saying it should have waited for the other side’s response. 

PTI leader Omar Ayub Khan announced the party’s decision to end further talks with the government on Thursday, saying that it would only resume negotiations to break political tensions if authorities established judicial commissions to investigate violence at anti-government protests organized by the PTI. 

Negotiations between the two sides kicked off in December 2024 after Khan threatened a civil disobedience movement. Both sides held three rounds of talks, and the government was expected to submit a formal response to the PTI’s demands on Jan. 28. 

“Minister for Information and Broadcasting Attaullah Tarar says Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf unilaterally terminated the dialogue process without any reason,” state broadcaster Radio Pakistan reported on Friday. 

The minister said the PTI should have waited for the government’s response to their demands, lamenting that it took the decision to end talks in a “hurry with ill intention.” 

Khan’s ouster in a parliamentary no-trust vote in 2022 has plunged Pakistan into a political crisis, particularly since he was jailed in August 2023 on corruption and other charges. His PTI party has regularly held protests to demand his release, with many of the demonstrations turning violent. 

But despite the government-opposition stalemate, Junaid Akbar Khan, a lawmaker from the PTI, was elected on Friday unopposed as the head of the National Assembly’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC), according to a statement issued by the National Assembly Secretariat. The post of the PAC chairman had been vacant since the general election in February last year.

The PTI’s demands to the government revolve around the release of all political prisoners including Khan, and the formation of two judicial commissions to probe into violent protest rallies, including one on May 9, 2023, when PTI supporters rampaged through military offices and installations, and a second one on Nov. 26, 2024 to demand Khan’s release, in which the government says four troops were killed.

So far, the government has remained tight-lipped on whether or not it would form the judicial commissions as per the PTI’s demands.


Pakistan president confers civilian award on citizen who saved pilgrims’ lives during Hajj 2024

Updated 25 January 2025
Follow

Pakistan president confers civilian award on citizen who saved pilgrims’ lives during Hajj 2024

  • Asif Bashir was instrumental in saving 17 pilgrims’ lives during Hajj 2024 when they fainted due to extreme heat
  • Indian Minister for Parliamentary and Minority Affairs Kiren Rijju also thanked Bashir in letter of gratitude last year

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s President Asif Ali Zardari this week conferred the country’s third highest civilian award on Asif Bashir, a Pakistani Hajj assistant who saved the lives of several pilgrims during last year’s pilgrimage after they fainted due to the extreme heat. 

Bashir was among 550 Pakistani Hajj Moavineen (assistants) recruited by the government to provide facilities to Pakistani pilgrims. However, they also provide facilities to pilgrims belonging to other countries.

Bashir, along with his five-member team, rushed to provide first aid to several pilgrims as they fainted to the ground while the temperature soared above 51 degrees last year. He was able to transport 26 to the hospital, most of whom were Indians. Nine of them died while 17 survived. 

“President Asif Ali Zardari on Friday conferred the Sitara-i-Imtiaz award on Asif Bashir in recognition of his outstanding services in the field of public services,” state-run Associated Press of Pakistan (APP) reported on Friday. 

The state-run media said Zardari conferred the award during a special investiture ceremony held at the Aiwan-e-Sadr or President House, which was attended by parliamentarians.

Bashir and his team were able to save the pilgrims by giving them water and ORS [Oral Rehydration Solution] and transporting those who needed medical attention to a nearby hospital that was almost 5-6 kilometers from their check-post.

Out of the 17 that Bashir was able to save, 15 were Indians, one was British and one was a Canadian national.

In recognition of Bashir’s efforts, Indian Minister for Parliamentary and Minority Affairs Kiren Rijju even wrote him a letter of gratitude.