KARACHI: A Pakistani high court on Friday directed the country’s top election body to hold local government elections in Pakistan’s southern port city of Karachi as well as Hyderabad within 60 days, a decision welcomed by almost all major parties in the two cities.
Local government polls were earlier scheduled for July 24 in Karachi and Hyderabad in Pakistan's southern Sindh province. However, flash floods triggered by monsoon rains and inadequate security to manage the polls caused several delays in the election date.
Following the delays in polling, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and the Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) parties moved the Sindh High Court (SHC) to ensure polls are conducted without further delays.
A two-member bench comprising SHC Chief justice Ahmed Ali M. Shaikh and Justice Yousuf Ali Sayeed directed the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to announce the date of local government elections within 15 days.
The ECP will announce its own decision on holding local government elections next Tuesday.
“The ECP may notify the polling date, preferably within a period of 15 days,” the court’s order read, adding the overall exercise of the election should be completed within 60 days.
The court said it dismissed petitions to challenge ECP’s earlier decision to postpone elections in August as the bench was “satisfied” that polls were postponed due to a valid excuse.
The court noted floodwater had receded in the areas and it was questionable whether law enforcers were unable to perform election duty as they were busy in relief operations.
“The election has now been repeatedly postponed for almost four months on that pretext, with a definite future date still not being in sight,” the judges noted.
“Suffice it to say that there has been considerable time for an appropriate solution to have been found, and the matter cannot indefinitely be kept in abeyance by the Provincial administration,” it added.
The court noted there is a shortage of 16,786 police personnel in Sindh. However, it observed that 5,000 Sindh Police personnel had been placed at the Inspector-General Islamabad Police’s disposal. The court also noted that a significant number had been deployed for the security of Pakistan’s largest annual defense exhibition, IDEAS 2022.
The court's decision was welcomed by almost all major parties in the two cities, except for the Muttahida Quami Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P). The MQM-P wanted to become a party to the PTI, JI petitions in court and wanted to delay the election process. The court, however, rejected its request.
MQM-P leader Khawaja Izhar Hassan called instead for empowering councilors, adding that unless they were given authority, people would never get their due rights.
He criticized major political parties, saying that the local government system was neither strengthened nor councilors empowered during their tenures.
“How can they speak about local government elections,” he asked.
Izhar alleged that 47,000 names on voter lists were of people who were aged above 100 years. “Over 17 local government departments and institutions do not answer to the mayor,” he lamented.
“It’s a welcome decision as the august judges haven’t determined the date but left it on the election commission, which is the legal and constitutional forum to decide,” Murtaza Wahab, administrator Karachi and Sindh government spokesperson, said.
Wahab said it was necessary for people to feel safe and secure when casting their votes. He said currently, providing that sense of security to voters at 4,990 polling stations, of which 1,300 were highly sensitive and to deploy 17,000 police officers was not possible.
Naeem-ur-Rehman, JI Karachi president and the party’s candidate for mayor, welcomed the court’s decision.
“We welcome the decision. The court has also directed the provincial government to provide security so if it makes any further excuse, the army and Rangers should be summoned for security,” Rehman told Arab News.
PTI lawmaker Khurram Sher Zaman also praised the decision, criticizing the government for saying on one hand it didn’t have enough law enforcers to arrange security and on the other hand, giving 5,000 police personnel to Islamabad.
“But after today’s order, the government may not further delay elections,” he said