Breaking barriers: How desert women from Pakistan’s Tharparkar defied odds to become active voters

In this file photo, taken on March 11, 2014, Pakistani villagers walk alongside the road in Mithi, the capital of Tharparkar district, some 300 kilometres from Karachi. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 07 February 2024
Follow

Breaking barriers: How desert women from Pakistan’s Tharparkar defied odds to become active voters

  • Registered women voter turnout in 2018 went as high as 72.8 percent in Tharparkar, though it stood at 7.8 percent in places like Shangla
  • Krishna Kumari Kohli, a female senator from the desert region, hopes to witness increased women voter turnout on Feb. 8

THARPARKAR/KARACHI: It took a national tragedy for Hanju Kolhi, a 70-year-old Hindu woman from a small settlement near Islamkot in Tharparkar district, to start voting.
Kolhi participated in her first national election in 2008 after never casting a ballot before. The shift in her attitude was prompted by the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in a gun-and-bomb attack while on the campaign trail in December 2007.
In subsequent years, Tharparkar’s desert region in the southern Sindh province witnessed a remarkable surge in women’s electoral participation, defying national trends. According to data analysis by the Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN), turnout rates for women voters in the area soared in 2018 to an unprecedented 72.8 percent in NA-221 and 71.4 percent in NA-222.
Contrast this with the starkly different situation in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s NA-10 Shangla and NA-48 North Waziristan. In these areas, women’s presence at polling stations was rare, and conservative cultural norms combined with logistical hurdles kept turnout abysmally low, with figures languishing at 7.8 percent and 8.2 percent, respectively.
Tharparkar also led with the highest women voter turnout in the 2018 general election for provincial assembly seats. Four out of the top five constituencies nationwide having the highest number of women voters were situated in Tharparkar — the first, second, third and fifth constituencies.
“In the elections following Benazir Bhutto’s assassination, I began to cast my vote,” Kolhi told Arab News. “It was a response to my conscience, as Benazir sacrificed her life for us. In return, I felt it was my duty to vote for her. Voting for her is a matter of life and death for me.”
Speaking to Arab News, Ali Akbar Rahimoo, executive director of a Tharparkar-based social welfare organization, Aware, acknowledged the people of the region had exhibited political awareness by voting in recent electoral contests in large numbers.
However, he added that women were impeded from participating in the democratic process in the past by other factors as well, such as the absence of Computerized National Identity Cards (CNIC), which they later secured for financial reasons.
“For availing the Benazir Income Support Program (BISP), a large number of women obtained national identity cards, thereby gaining access to the voting rolls,” he said.
Rahimoo informed the National Database Registration Authority (NADRA), which issues CNICs to citizens, also became more accessible to the residents of the area, ensuring greater mobility among the populace in the arid region surrounded by a sprawling desert.
“While these cards have undoubtedly played a significant role, other factors have also influenced female voter turnout,” he said. “There was no drought in Tharparkar, and as such, no seasonal migration during the 2018 election, meaning that people remained in their constituencies and were able to vote.”
In the 2024 elections, Mehar-un-Nisa, an independent candidate backed by former Prime Minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party, is vying for NA-215 (previously NA-221) from Tharparkar. She stands as the sole female candidate in the district who is running for a general seat either for the national or provincial assembly seat.
“Tharparkar suffers from poverty where people lack basic facilities,” she told Arab News. “Among them, Hindu minority women are the most deprived. This is the major reason they are very active in casting votes in an attempt to secure basic facilities from elected representatives.”
However, she noted that national parties often neglected to nominate women to contest for general seats, despite benefiting from their vote. Nisa maintained that the PTI, on the other hand, had a commitment to gender equality that was evident from her own nomination for the National Assembly general seat.
Krishna Kumari Kohli, a Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) senator who holds the distinction of being the sole female parliamentarian in any legislative house to represent Tharparkar, said this was due to the lack of applications received by political parties from women candidates.
“In the past, Tharparkar saw limited participation of women in active politics,” she said. “However, the landscape is evolving, with the PPP leading by example through my election as the first senator from the district. It won’t be long before we witness multiple Tharparkar women representatives in legislative houses.”
The senator attributed the growing number of women voters to the expanding road network, increased access to education and heightened political awareness. Due to these factors, she added, the region was likely to witness an increased turnout of women voters in Tharparkar in the February 8 elections.
Nadia Naqi, a Karachi-based analyst, said the high turnout of women casting their ballots in Tharparkar primarily owed to its “open society.”
“When you go to rural areas in Sindh, you don’t see women who are always behind closed doors,” she said, adding that though women in some areas observed the veil, one could see many of them working in the fields.

Mentioning Shangla in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, she observed it was a society where women were not allowed to participate in public life.
“They are behind closed doors; there’s a totally different culture,” she said, noting there were cases when male candidates from different parties decided to prevent women from casting their votes. Naqi urged that women’s turnout should be increased across the country.
According to FAFEN officials, civil society groups have established effective coordination mechanisms with government departments, particularly the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) and NADRA, to mobilize women for voter registration.
These efforts, Rukhsana Shama of FAFEN told Arab News, included identification of cultural barriers to women’s registration and deploying mobile registration vehicles to underserved areas.
The coordination between the ECP and NADRA, she said, had increased the number of women voters from 2018 to 2024.
“This increase has been unprecedented because this is the first time that the ratio of women being registered as voters has been more than the men,” she said.
The FAFEN official informed that the registration deficit had decreased to 9.9 million from 12.7 million, which existed earlier.
With increased awareness, women residents of Tharparkar, like the 57-year-old Sangeeta Goel, plan to vote in the next elections.
“Women should cast their votes and elect rulers who care about them and resolve their issues,” she said.

 


Pakistan voices ‘deep regret’ as US vetoes UN Security Council resolution on Gaza ceasefire

Updated 21 November 2024
Follow

Pakistan voices ‘deep regret’ as US vetoes UN Security Council resolution on Gaza ceasefire

  • 15-member UN council voted on a resolution put forward by 10 non-permanent members 
  • Only US voted against, using its veto as permanent council member to block resolution

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan on Thursday expressed “deep regret” over the United States vetoing a UN Security Council resolution for a ceasefire in Gaza, which has drawn criticism of the Biden administration for once again blocking international action aimed at halting Israel’s war in the besieged enclave. 

The 15-member council voted on a resolution put forward by 10 non-permanent members that called for an “immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire” in the 13-month conflict and separately demanded the release of hostages. Only the US voted against it, using its veto as a permanent council member to block the resolution.

“We deeply regret that even now a resolution calling for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire has been vetoed by the sole negative vote of a permanent member of the Council,” Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the UN, Munir Akram, told the state APP news agency. 

Robert Wood, deputy US ambassador to the UN, said Washington had made clear it would only support a resolution that explicitly called for the immediate release of hostages as part of a ceasefire.

“A durable end to the war must come with the release of the hostages. These two urgent goals are inextricably linked. This resolution abandoned that necessity, and for that reason, the United States could not support it,” he said.

Wood said the US had sought compromise, but the text of the proposed resolution would have sent a “dangerous message” to Hamas that “there’s no need to come back to the negotiating table.”

Israel’s campaign in Gaza has killed nearly 44,000 people and displaced nearly all of the enclave’s population at least once. It was launched in response to an attack by Hamas fighters who killed 1,200 people and captured more than 250 hostages in Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.

With inputs from Reuters


Gulf countries have identified $19 billion investment portfolio for Pakistan — planning minister

Updated 36 min 10 sec ago
Follow

Gulf countries have identified $19 billion investment portfolio for Pakistan — planning minister

  • Pakistan has been pushing for foreign investment in recent months in a bid to shore up its $350 billion economy
  • Rollovers, loans from Saudi Arabia, UAE, China have helped Pakistan meet external financing needs in the past

ISLAMABAD: Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal said on Thursday Gulf nations like Saudi Arabia and the UAE, among others, had identified a $19 billion investment portfolio for Pakistan, while China was now entering phase two of a multi-billion-dollar economic corridor project. 

Pakistan has been pushing for foreign investment in recent months in a bid to shore up its $350 billion economy as it navigates a tough reforms agenda mandated by the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

“The world, which was viewing Pakistan as a failed economy, is once more looking at Pakistan with hope,” Iqbal said as he addressed a ceremony in Islamabad. 

“China is extending its hand in the form of phase two of CPEC [China-Pakistan Economic Corridor]. Our friendly nations, Gulf countries, which include Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait, Qatar, Azerbaijan, they have together identified a $19 billion portfolio under which they can invest in Pakistan. So, all these opportunities are once again knocking at our door.”

Rollovers or disbursements on loans from Pakistan’s long-time allies Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and China, in addition to financing from the IMF, have helped Pakistan meet its external financing needs in the past.

Last month, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia signed investment agreements worth $2.8 billion while Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has pledged to expedite a $5 billion investment portfolio for Islamabad.

The UAE committed this May it would invest $10 billion in promising economic sectors. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif also said this week Azerbaijan had pledged to invest $3 billion in multiple sectors of Pakistan’s economy. 

Pakistan and the IMF signed a $7 billion loan program in September. 

Pakistan’s economy has struggled for decades with boom-and-bust cycles, needing 23 IMF bailouts since 1958.


Two new species of cobia fish found off Gwadar coast in northern Arabian Sea

Updated 21 November 2024
Follow

Two new species of cobia fish found off Gwadar coast in northern Arabian Sea

  • New study published in the peer-reviewed academic journal Zoologischer Anzeiger
  • Research team found species during study of commercially popular black king cobia 

ISLAMABAD: Two newly identified species of the cobia fish have been found off Pakistan’s Gwadar coast in the northern Arabian Sea, according to a new study published in the peer-reviewed academic journal Zoologischer Anzeiger, whose latest edition came out this month.

The cobia is a species of marine carangiform ray-finned fish, whose other common names include black kingfish, black salmon, ling, lemonfish, crabeater, prodigal son, codfish, and black bonito.

“This study describes two newly identified species, Rachycentron blochii sp. nov. and Rachycentron makranesis sp. nov. from Gwadar in the northern Arabian Sea,” said the study, authored by Dr. Sher Khan Panhwar and Dr. Imtiaz Kashani, professors at the Center of Excellence in Marine Biology at the University of Karachi.

“The newly discovered species differ significantly from their relatives in multiple morphological traits, such as head profile, mouth, pectoral fin, caudal fin, caudal peduncle, dorsal and anal fin bases, gill rakers, and body coloration.”

The recent finding increases the number of cobia species in the northern Arabian Sea, Pakistan, the study says, presenting information on the species’ biological and ecological aspects such as feeding habits, age assessment, habitat preferences and fishery-related details.

The research was financially supported by the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan through its National Research Programme for Universities project.

“At first glance, I thought it was another black king cobia but when I looked closer at the markings on its body, I knew it was different,” Dr. Panhwar told Pakistan’s Dawn newspaper, explaining that he was traveling with students on a routine survey of the Gwadar fish harbor last year when he spotted the new species. The team was there to study the black king cobia or Rachycentron canadum, a commercially popular large fish found around the world.

Fresh specimens weighing between 4 and 7 kg were immediately cooled in dry-ice and packed into ice boxes for transportation to the fisheries laboratory at the University of Karachi, some 650km away from the Gwadar harbor.

Back at the laboratory, Dr. Pan­hwar and his colleague Dr. Kashani analyzed the unusual cobias, examining their appearance, dissecting them, and comparing them with the typical species. 

The two new species have been named the Blotchy Cobia, a nod to the large gray markings found on its body as well as to the Balochi language spoken in the region. The other one will be called Makran Cobia, named after the Makran coast where it was found.

“At this time, these species of cobia have only been spotted in Pakistan,” Panhwar told Dawn.


After bail in state gifts case, new charges filed against Pakistan’s Imran Khan

Updated 21 November 2024
Follow

After bail in state gifts case, new charges filed against Pakistan’s Imran Khan

  • Khan has been named in case relating to alleged violence by his supporters during a rally in September 
  • Khan, who has been in jail since August 2023, says all cases against him are politically motivated 

ISLAMABAD: Rawalpindi police said on Thursday they had filed fresh charges against former Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan related to violence at a party rally in September, a day after a court granted the ex-premier bail in a case involving the illegal sale of gifts from a state repository. 

On Wednesday, the Islamabad High Court granted Khan bail in the new Toshakhana case, filed in July and involving a jewelry set worth over €380,000 gifted to the former first lady by a foreign dignitary when Khan was prime minister from 2018-2022. The couple is accused of undervaluing the gift and buying it at a lesser price from the state repository.

Before the new case was filed, Khan, who has been in jail since last August, was convicted in four cases. Two of the cases have since been suspended, including an original one relating to state gifts, while he was acquitted in the remaining two.

“A case has been registered for arson, stone pelting, resisting the police, damage to government property and other incidents,” Rawalpindi Police announced on X, reading the charges against Khan in connection to a protest held by his Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party in September. 

“Investigation team headed by SSP Investigation is investigating Imran Khan. Khan will be produced in court to obtain physical remand.”

Charges have also been filed in the case against Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur and a number of PTI leaders, including Seemabia Tahir, Amir Mughar and Aliya Hamza.

The police report of the case, which was filed on Sept. 28, the day of the rally, lists terrorism, attempted murder, vandalism, destruction of public and state property, and interference in government operations as the main charges. It says participants of the PTI rally created unrest, obstructed public access by burning tires and caused difficulties for citizens.

It also charges PTI leaders and supporters of raising anti-government slogans, hurling stones at the police and attacking them with iron rods during the protest.

Several police vehicles were damaged by PTI rallygoers and one police officer was injured, the report says.

Khan was in prison when the Sept. 28 rally took place. The former premier denies any wrongdoing, and alleges all the cases registered against him since he was removed from power in 2022 are politically motivated to keep him in jail.


Pakistani PM thanks King Salman, Gates foundations for global anti-polio efforts

Updated 21 November 2024
Follow

Pakistani PM thanks King Salman, Gates foundations for global anti-polio efforts

  • Pakistan, along with neighboring Afghanistan, remains last polio-endemic country in the world
  • This year, 50 cases have been reported in Pakistan so far, a majority in Balochistan province 

ISLAMABAD: Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday met a delegation of the Polio Oversight Board in Islamabad and thanked the King Salman and Bill & Melinda Gates foundations, among others, in their global efforts for polio eradication.

Pakistan, along with neighboring Afghanistan, remains the last polio-endemic country in the world. The nation’s polio eradication campaign has hit serious problems with a spike in reported cases this year that has prompted officials to review their approach to stopping the crippling disease.

Poliovirus, which can cause crippling paralysis particularly in young children, is incurable and remains a threat to human health as long as it has not been eradicated. Immunization campaigns have succeeded in most countries and have come close in Pakistan, but persistent problems remain.

“The Prime Minister thanked the King Salman Foundation, Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Rotary Foundation, UNICEF and CDC, which are partners with the Government of Pakistan in the polio eradication campaign,” Sharif’s office said in a statement after the meeting. 

“The role of all these organizations reflects the global efforts in the polio eradication campaign.”

This year, 50 cases have been reported in Pakistan: 24 from Balochistan province, 13 from Sindh, 10 from KP and one each from Punjab and Islamabad. 

In the early 1990s, Pakistan reported around 20,000 cases annually but in 2018 the number dropped to eight cases. Six cases were reported in 2023 and only one in 2021. 

Pakistan’s polio eradication program began in 1994, and the number of cases has declined dramatically since then. But efforts to eradicate the virus have for years been undermined by vaccine misinformation and opposition from some religious hard-liners, who say immunization is a foreign ploy to sterilize Muslim children or a cover for Western spies. Militant groups also frequently attack and kill members of polio vaccine teams. 

In July 2019, a vaccination drive in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa was thwarted after mass panic was created by rumors that children were fainting or vomiting after being immunized.

Public health studies in Pakistan have shown that maternal illiteracy and low parental knowledge about vaccines, together with poverty and rural residency, are also factors that commonly influence whether parents vaccinate their children against polio.

Pakistan’s chief health officer this month said an estimated 500,000 children had missed polio vaccinations during a recent countrywide inoculation drive due to vaccine refusals.